| Female Toby | Male Toby | Most Improved Female | Most Improved Male | Cory award | |
| Orange | Carolyn Ernest | David Shea | Gwen Matuszek | Steve Passafero | Ian Feldman |
| White Paper Tigers | Lissa Kanner | Ricky Wolfsdorf | Rebecca Gold | Ryan Tanner | Kareem Reda |
| Black Mamba | Celinda Gourd | Colin Meikeljohn | Monique LeBourgeoise | Pat McNally | Elliot Bock |
| Brown | Jess Vosbury | Mike Pozar | Amanda Brown | Donnelley Roberts | Mike Merrill |
| Daisy | Kira Lawrence | Ryan "Woody" Woodward | Hannah Vu | Bob Bozikowski | Jeff Fleischaker |
| Yellow Haze | Sarah McAndrew | Cass Sapir | Carly Blair | Casey Marks | Jimmy Medeiros |
| Blue Velvet | June Park | Brian Thurber | Abbey Wilson | Luke Woloszyn | Chris Brady |
| Hot Damn (Red) | Christine Gould | Jason Leroux | Grace Shih | Dev Benarjee | Andrew Dixon |
| Leaf | Kit Wallach | Jeremy Katzen | Michelle Levinson | Peter Skwitz | Luke Olson |
| Purple | Josie Dutil | Jason Donahue | Julie Penner | Colin Heikes | Chris Sanosi |
The Toby Award goes to the player who best exemplifies what we as a league are striving for, namely, superior play, excellent spirit, good leadership, and just being an all-around good guy.